I have been trying out different ways to make vegan yogurt, but so far all of my attempts have failed horribly. There is nothing fun about waking up to a weird and pungeant smell and realizing that it is the soy yogurt experiment that has gone wrong… really wrong!
Last week however, I realized that I had some boxes of coconut milk in my pantry and that they were about to go bad. I decided that this was the perfect excuse to try making vegan yogurt again.
Now, my budget this summer is pretty tight, so there was no way I was going to spend 50$ (and maybe more) on probiotic pills. I know that these little pills would mean that I would be able to make hundreds of batches of vegan yogurt, but no. I went to my trusted local health food store, and realized that they didn’t even have those pills. So, double no. They did have already made coconut yougurt however. After checking the ingredients and seeing the “live cultures” listed as part of the ingredients, I decided that I could spare this 6$ for my experiment.
The process of making yogurt is fairly simple. You mix live cultures with your milk, stir everything well, let this sit overnight in a warm place, move everything to the fridge, and voila! I used to love making goat’s milk yogurt and kefir before going vegan, so my hopes were up on this coconut yogurt.
Here is what I used:
- 1L coconut milk
- 350g plain store-bought coconut yogurt (I used the one from Silk)
Here is what I did:
- In a large container, I mixed the coconut milk and the yogurt with a wisk until everything was homogenous.
- I covered the top of my container with a paper towel tied with a rubber band and placed it in my oven (with the light turned on).
- 12 hours later I moved the container to the fridge and let the yogurt set for 8 more hours.
The result? Well, you have two options here. The fattier part of the coconut milk yogurt will gatter to the top of your container and give you this incredibly thick and rich yogurt. The bottom part will be more liquid and perfect to add to smoothies. The first option is to keep these two phases separate and to enjoy the great diversity that this recipe gives you. The second option is to take out your trusty wisk and to wisk everything together. The result will be a smooth drinkable yogurt that is perfect for parfaits and smoothies. I have to say I did both and can’t believe how thick and creamy the top layer is.
The taste of this yogurt is tangy with the slightest coconut aftertaste. It really is super smooth and so delicious. Now, for the next batch, just remember to keep 1 cup of already made yogurt that you will use as a starter. Infinite vegan yogurt, here we come!
9 thoughts on “Coconut yogurt: this time it worked!”
This sounds so simple and it will save me a fortune! Do you know if you can then use the coconut yoghurt you’ve made as the live cultures for the next batch of coconut milk to keep it going? Definitely want to give this a try! Thanks for sharing the recipe 😋
Yes! Absolutely! I tried it twice already and it worked: you can reuse your own yogurt to make more 😊
Haven’t made yogurt for years, I used to love it but never tried coconut yogurt. Thank you 😄
Let me know if you try this out 😊
Could you use canned coconut milk whixh contains more fat hence creamier yoghurt. And how long does this last if making big batch and you want to keep 1cup for the next batch.
Hi! Yes you could definitely use just the cream from a can of coconut milk: just keep in mind that that will yield less yogurt. The yogurt keeps for about 7 to 10 days in the fridge. Let me know if you try it out 🙂
Thanks. I had no idea it was this simple! Just some patience 😉
It’s often the key to success!!! 🙂